Anonymous
August 20, 2026 at 6:55:02 AM
- Who's/Which Mafia were you on? ♡:
vista's mafia
Sorry for bad English, English not my first language and I am still learning it
The host should write the rules beforehand, and I don't think they should even say that people with permissions are the ones playing(I think that is the word?) and the one with no permissions are the spectators. It is common sense in most mafias I have played in. Also, they don't need to say "disclaimer" when saying that they are going to use the party chat.
-> A disclaimer is a formal statement used to limit legal responsibility, liability, or the scope of rights between parties. It acts as a warning to set clear expectations and protect a person or business from certain claims or damages. / Warns that content (such as medical, financial, or legal advice) is for informational purposes only and does not replace an expert.
If you are going to send the roles in party chat, I don't even think you should give us time to read. We can just go scroll on the party chat to see the roles, and there were only 26 showcased.
In the ad, the mafia was advertised as "detailed". In terms of the map, it is detailed and it is very beautiful. But for the roles? In my opinion, it's not as detailed. It is less interesting and just plain. You do not need to add more roles, you just need to modify/adjust it. The innocent role is not mentioned too. If you are an innocent, it'll just feel like you're spectating while also playing.
Almost all good team roles are basic mafia roles (except Time Keeper and Manager), same goes for neutral team roles. ねこ is basically just a fox. Evil team roles are basic too. I have heard of "evil cook" before from another mafia back in 2025. It just feels really useless to include secret roles, especially when only around 12 players were playing. 23 roles were showcased, 26 if you include secret roles.
For the map, it is very beautiful but hard to get around. Especially with the amount of those window things.
The hosting was boring for me. It was not as entertaining as I would find other mafias. While I am writing this part, there are only 8 players left. More than half of the party was just spectating and went offline. I feel like there should be NPC interactions, or at least dialogues so it does not feel boring and empty. Because that is how it felt for me. This might just be because I prefer interactive mafias rather than normal Pony Town mafias. Also, I feel like it is useless to keep spectators in the mafia unless they are observing, or learning on how to play a Mafia, or there with a friend who is playing. If they join the Mafia just to hangout, they should just join a hangout instead.
The clues are really basic too. I have yet to see a Mafia that actually has original and interesting clues.
That is all. Sorry if some things are not worded well, or sounded just completely wrong, I am still learning English.
Overall rating: 7/10. Just two above average.
Replied on: August 20, 2026 at 7:22:25 AM
Alright, Vista here. I apologize for wording some of it wrong because like i said, i was really tired and drowsy in this mafia because i do have my personal problems. The map was advertised as detailed, the roles were not, for the roles, i want them to be understandable for everyone, especially for people who has trouble understanding, dyslexia and etc, and having more detailed and long explanations for putting in the partychat. So, we first started off with 22 members, that IS why i put 23 roles in the notifications, and yes, i am COMPLETELY aware that neko means fox, it’s themed. I usually don’t use the innocent role because we just have lots of roles, and we replace it with our neutral roles instead. My mafia is NOT roleplay or a lore based mafia, i’d really appreciate it if you did NOT compare our mafias to lore based mafias.
I don't know I think I forgot something but don't take this rudely I'm just really tired of waiting (I'm still in the mafia and spoiler alert: they still havent started giving out roles yet)
(